Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on telegram
Share on whatsapp
Share on linkedin
Share on print
Share on email

Risk Watch: China’s Local Debt ‘Iceberg’ Emits ‘Cracking Sounds’

◎ Based on our estimate, implicit debt in some cities and counties was three to four times higher that of their public debt.

Caijing Magazine’s 16th issue of 2018 (published on July 9) featured a cover page with a man hauling a piggy bank atop a cracking iceberg. The headline read: “The Worries of Local Debt Hanging High Overhead.” The cover page article likened China’s local government implicit debt to an iceberg, with a small portion publicly visible and a large volume hidden beneath the surface. In the article, a local government economic researcher noted that “faint cracking sounds” can be heard from the “icebergs” in provinces such as Guizhou, Yunnan, and other regions in western China.

On July 16, the state-run China Securities Journal reported that multiple government departments are launching investigations into local government implicit debt. The investigations would span at least all city-level governments. Random inspections could be conducted at the county and district levels. The purpose of the probe is to get to the bottom of local government implicit debt risks before measures are formulated to address the risks.

More from Caijing on the local government debt ‘iceberg’:

1. The various government departments in the Chinese regime use different standards to calculate local government implicit debt. Hence, no official data on implicit debt has been published.

2. Reports from third-party organizations note that many Chinese local governments owe debt that exceeds the 60 percent figure that is regarded as reasonable by international standards.

  • According to China’s Ministry of Finance (MoF) data, central government debt ratio was 36.2 percent at the end of 2017, far below the prudent 60 percent level.
  • Liu Shangxi, the president of the Chinese Academy of Fiscal Sciences, believes that local government implicit debts encompasses a very broad scope of items, including loans for construction work, consumer projects, policy financing guarantee, local government financing platforms, shantytown redevelopment projects, public-private partnership (PPP) projects, government purchase of services, local “zombie” state-owned enterprises, poverty alleviation projects, and pension payments.
  • In some regions across China, a considerable number of local government financing platforms do not have the means to be independently solvent and generally lack a stable stream of income. These platforms rely on government and rolling financing to survive, and have substantial hidden debt risks.
  • According to the findings of a research team led by Zhang Xiaojing, the deputy director the National Institution for Finance & Development, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, “the current local government financing platform debt is about 30 trillion yuan, or about 40 percent of China’s GDP.”
  • Another research team led by Bai Zhongen, the executive associate dean of Tsinghua University’s School of Economics and Management, concluded that the “corporate debt balance of bonds issued by city governments” was about 47 trillion yuan as of the end of June 2017.
  • If the implicit debt of local government financing platforms is included in the Chinese government’s debt leverage, then the Chinese government’s debt by the middle of 2017 is 65 percent of the GDP, passing the 60 percent debt threshold that is the international standard.

3. The central government has only effective in curbing public debt. Local implicit debt, however, is several times that of public debt, and implicit debt is now a “bottomless pit” due to years of accumulation.

4. The debt risks of the western Chinese provinces has worsened. Guizhou is the province with the most severe debt risks, be it public debt or implicit debt.

5. Most government departments and research institutions only pay attention to the debt risk at the provincial-level, and rarely pay attention to the situation in the cities and counties. But the debt problem in the counties and cities is more severe than at the provincial-level, and it needs to be sorted out “as soon as possible.”

The big picture:
The Sino-U.S. trade war does not appear to be de-escalating in the short term, and in fact, could escalate due to the Chinese Communist Party’s natural inclination to retaliate and not show weakness. The trade war has already caused China’s stock markets to plummet and the renminbi exchange rate to the U.S. dollar to fall sharply.

Meanwhile, signs that China’s economy is continually worsening keep emerging. In the first half of 2018, several companies have defaulted on bonds while peer-to-peer lending platforms are shutting shop one after the other (at least 57 in July and 80 in June). Also, civil servants in some parts of China have carried out protests to demand their wages, and retired military veterans held demonstrations outside government buildings in Beijing and elsewhere to ask for welfare benefits promised to them, and complain that their rights have been abused.

Our take:
1. The CCP elites do not seem to have a solution for defusing the Sino-U.S. trade conflict or preventing it from adversely affecting the already troubled Chinese economy. Presently, Beijing seems to be stalling for time with the U.S. But delaying tactics are merely stopgap in resolving the trade war and China’s economic woes. The local implicit debt situation is already very severe and would only grow more serious with time. And the CCP elites currently do not have a grasp of the full picture to begin tackling the problem.

2. According to the data from the investigations cited in the Caijing article, the total Chinese government debt by the end of 2017 was over 60 trillion yuan. Based on our understanding of the CCP regime, the actual debt figure is likely much higher.

In an April article, we estimated China’s implicit debt in 2017 to be four times the official debt balance (16.47 trillion yuan), or about 82.35 trillion yuan (99.56 percent of China’s 2017 GDP). We based our estimate on official reporting of the situation in the provinces of Inner Mongolia and Ningxia, where implicit debt in some cities and counties was three to four times higher that of their public debt.

3. As the Sino-U.S. trade war escalates, China’s exports would decline sharply and local governments would generate far lesser revenue. In the past two months, local governments in Inner Mongolia and Guizhou have already defaulted on so-called city investment bonds. As local governments collect less revenue, the probability of local governments defaulting on bonds would rise sharply.

If cash-strapped local governments delay paying wages to civil servants, the CCP will run into law enforcement and “security maintenance” problems. In this scenario, Chinese society would likely see tremendous change.

Search past entries by date
“The breadth of SinoInsider’s insights—from economics through the military to governance, all underpinned by unparalleled reporting on the people in charge—is stunning. In my over fifty years of in-depth reading on the PRC, unclassified and classified, SinoInsider is in a class all by itself.”
James Newman, Former U.S. Navy cryptologist
“Unique insights are available frequently from the reports of Sinoinsider.”
Michael Pillsbury, Senior Fellow for China Strategy, The Heritage Foundation
“Thank you for your information and analysis. Very useful.”
Prof. Ravni Thakur, University of Delhi, India
“SinoInsider’s research has helped me with investing in or getting out of Chinese companies.”
Charles Nelson, Managing Director, Murdock Capital Partners
“I value SinoInsider because of its always brilliant articles touching on, to name just a few, CCP history, current trends, and factional politics. Its concise and incisive analysis — absent the cliches that dominate China policy discussions in DC and U.S. corporate boardrooms — also represents a major contribution to the history of our era by clearly defining the threat the CCP poses to American peace and prosperity and global stability. I am grateful to SinoInsider — long may it thrive!”
Lee Smith, Author and journalist
“Your publication insights tremendously help us complete our regular analysis on in-depth issues of major importance. ”
Ms. Nicoleta Buracinschi, Embassy of Romania to the People’s Republic of China
"I’m a very happy, satisfied subscriber to your service and all the deep information it provides to increase our understanding. SinoInsider is profoundly helping to alter the public landscape when it comes to the PRC."
James Newman, Former U.S. Navy cryptologist
“Prof. Ming’s information about the Sino-U.S. trade war is invaluable for us in Taiwan’s technology industry. Our company basically acted on Prof. Ming’s predictions and enlarged our scale and enriched our product lines. That allowed us to deal capably with larger orders from China in 2019. ”
Mr. Chiu, Realtek R&D Center
“I am following China’s growing involvement in the Middle East, seeking to gain a better understanding of China itself and the impact of domestic constraints on its foreign policy. I have found SinoInsider quite helpful in expanding my knowledge and enriching my understanding of the issues at stake.”
Ehud Yaari, Lafer International Fellow, The Washington Institute
“SinoInsider’s research on the CCP examines every detail in great depth and is a very valuable reference. Foreign researchers will find SinoInsider’s research helpful in understanding what is really going on with the CCP and China. ”
Baterdene, Researcher, The National Institute for Security Studies (Mongolian)
“The forecasts of Prof. Chu-cheng Ming and the SinoInsider team are an invaluable resource in guiding our news reporting direction and anticipating the next moves of the Chinese and Hong Kong governments.”
Chan Miu-ling, Radio Television Hong Kong China Team Deputy Leader
“SinoInsider always publishes interesting and provocative work on Chinese elite politics. It is very worthwhile to follow the work of SinoInsider to get their take on factional struggles in particular.”
Lee Jones, Reader in International Politics, Queen Mary University of London
“[SinoInsider has] been very useful in my class on American foreign policy because it contradicts the widely accepted argument that the U.S. should work cooperatively with China. And the whole point of the course is to expose students to conflicting approaches to contemporary major problems.”
Roy Licklider, Adjunct Professor of Political Science, Columbia University
“As a China-based journalist, SinoInsider is to me a very reliable source of information to understand deeply how the CCP works and learn more about the factional struggle and challenges that Xi Jinping may face. ”
Sebastien Ricci, AFP correspondent for China & Mongolia
“SinoInsider offers an interesting perspective on the Sino-U.S. trade war and North Korea. Their predictions are often accurate, which is definitely very helpful.”
Sebastien Ricci, AFP correspondent for China & Mongolia
“I have found SinoInsider to provide much greater depth and breadth of coverage with regard to developments in China. The subtlety of the descriptions of China's policy/political processes is absent from traditional media channels.”
John Lipsky, Peter G. Peterson Distinguished Scholar, Kissinger Center for Global Affairs
“My teaching at Cambridge and policy analysis for the UK audience have been informed by insights from your analyzes. ”
Dr Kun-Chin Lin, University Lecturer in Politics,
Deputy Director of the Centre for Geopolitics, Cambridge University
" SinoInsider's in-depth and nuanced analysis of Party dynamics is an excellent template to train future Sinologists with a clear understanding that what happens in the Party matters."
Stephen Nagy, Senior Associate Professor, International Christian University
“ I find Sinoinsider particularly helpful in instructing students about the complexities of Chinese politics and what elite competition means for the future of the US-China relationship.”
Howard Sanborn, Professor, Virginia Military Institute
“SinoInsider has been one of my most useful (and enjoyable) resources”
James Newman, Former U.S. Navy cryptologist
“Professor Ming and his team’s analyses of current affairs are very far-sighted and directionally accurate. In the present media environment where it is harder to distinguish between real and fake information, SinoInsider’s professional perspectives are much needed to make sense of a perilous and unpredictable world. ”
Liu Cheng-chuan, Professor Emeritus, National Chiayi University