Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on telegram
Share on whatsapp
Share on linkedin
Share on print
Share on email

Risk Watch: Cremated Ashes in Wuhan Hint at a Suppressed Coronavirus Death Toll

◎ The following analysis was first published in the March 26 edition of our subscriber-only SinoWeekly Plus newsletter. Subscribe to SinoInsider to view past analyses in our newsletter archive.


On March 26, semi-official mainland news outlet The Paper published a story on the return of ashes to relatives of the deceased by Wuchang Funeral House in Wuhan City. Wuchang Funeral House staff said that they had returned 100 boxes of ashes per day from March 23 to March 24, and “strived” to return 500 boxes of ashes per day starting from March 25, with the hope that all ashes could be handed out before the Qingming Festival (April 5). Many of the families collecting ashes were accompanied by members of local district neighborhood committees. The article was subsequently deleted from The Paper’s site.

According to official PRC data, there were 2,531 coronavirus deaths in Wuhan as of March 25.

Our take:
1. The information in the now-deleted report in The Paper that we mentioned above challenges the official PRC data concerning the number of coronavirus deaths in Wuhan.

If we take the information in The Paper’s article at face value, then Wuchang Funeral House had 6,200 boxes of ashes to return before the Qingming Festival (200 boxes were handled out from March 23 to March 24; 6,000 boxes would be returned from March 25 to April 5 presuming a constant return rate of 500 boxes per day). According to publicly available information, there are seven funeral homes in Wuhan operating 79 cremation furnaces, 18 of which are located at Wuchang Funeral House. If we take the boxes of ashes that Wuchang Funeral House has as a percentage of the total (22.8 percent), then the funeral houses in Wuhan could possess as many as 27,192 boxes of ashes, with one box of ash corresponding to one person.

Given that Wuhan was placed under lockdown after the CCP acknowledged the coronavirus outbreak, it is likely that the bulk of the ashes being released now by Wuchang Funeral House are from those who died after Jan. 23. The 27,192 boxes of ashes does not capture all the deaths in Wuhan over the past two months, as some families could have retrieved their ashes earlier, or other funeral houses in Wuhan could have cremated more or less bodies than the Wuchang Funeral House did. That being said, it is likely that most of those who died after Jan. 23 died from either the “CCP virus” or from lack of medical attention due to hospitals being overwhelmed by the coronavirus epidemic.

In the Jan. 30 edition of this newsletter, we estimated that the actual coronavirus death rate could be at least 35 times higher than what the PRC had officially announced at the time. A notice by Wuhan’s Bureau of Civil Affairs also noted that funeral homes in Wuhan were operating their crematoriums for 24 hours a day, and only provided services for the “delivery of remains, cremation of remains, and the storage of ashes.”

2. Recent videos posted to Chinese social media show long lines outside Piandanshan Cemetery in Wuhan as people queue up to register the burial of their loved ones. Netizens comment that the lines outside the cemetery are longer than the lines for property sale lotteries, and that some families do not even have a queue number even after spending three hours in the queue.

"I’m a very happy, satisfied subscriber to your service and all the deep information it provides to increase our understanding. SinoInsider is profoundly helping to alter the public landscape when it comes to the PRC."
James Newman, Former U.S. Navy cryptologist
“Prof. Ming’s information about the Sino-U.S. trade war is invaluable for us in Taiwan’s technology industry. Our company basically acted on Prof. Ming’s predictions and enlarged our scale and enriched our product lines. That allowed us to deal capably with larger orders from China in 2019. ”
Mr. Chiu, Realtek R&D Center
“I am following China’s growing involvement in the Middle East, seeking to gain a better understanding of China itself and the impact of domestic constraints on its foreign policy. I have found SinoInsider quite helpful in expanding my knowledge and enriching my understanding of the issues at stake.”
Ehud Yaari, Lafer International Fellow, The Washington Institute
“SinoInsider’s research on the CCP examines every detail in great depth and is a very valuable reference. Foreign researchers will find SinoInsider’s research helpful in understanding what is really going on with the CCP and China. ”
Baterdene, Researcher, The National Institute for Security Studies (Mongolian)
“The forecasts of Prof. Chu-cheng Ming and the SinoInsider team are an invaluable resource in guiding our news reporting direction and anticipating the next moves of the Chinese and Hong Kong governments.”
Chan Miu-ling, Radio Television Hong Kong China Team Deputy Leader
“SinoInsider always publishes interesting and provocative work on Chinese elite politics. It is very worthwhile to follow the work of SinoInsider to get their take on factional struggles in particular.”
Lee Jones, Reader in International Politics, Queen Mary University of London
“[SinoInsider has] been very useful in my class on American foreign policy because it contradicts the widely accepted argument that the U.S. should work cooperatively with China. And the whole point of the course is to expose students to conflicting approaches to contemporary major problems.”
Roy Licklider, Adjunct Professor of Political Science, Columbia University
“As a China-based journalist, SinoInsider is to me a very reliable source of information to understand deeply how the CCP works and learn more about the factional struggle and challenges that Xi Jinping may face. ”
Sebastien Ricci, AFP correspondent for China & Mongolia
“SinoInsider offers an interesting perspective on the Sino-U.S. trade war and North Korea. Their predictions are often accurate, which is definitely very helpful.”
Sebastien Ricci, AFP correspondent for China & Mongolia
“I have found SinoInsider to provide much greater depth and breadth of coverage with regard to developments in China. The subtlety of the descriptions of China's policy/political processes is absent from traditional media channels.”
John Lipsky, Peter G. Peterson Distinguished Scholar, Kissinger Center for Global Affairs
“My teaching at Cambridge and policy analysis for the UK audience have been informed by insights from your analyzes. ”
Dr Kun-Chin Lin, University Lecturer in Politics,
Deputy Director of the Centre for Geopolitics, Cambridge University
" SinoInsider's in-depth and nuanced analysis of Party dynamics is an excellent template to train future Sinologists with a clear understanding that what happens in the Party matters."
Stephen Nagy, Senior Associate Professor, International Christian University
“ I find Sinoinsider particularly helpful in instructing students about the complexities of Chinese politics and what elite competition means for the future of the US-China relationship.”
Howard Sanborn, Professor, Virginia Military Institute
“SinoInsider has been one of my most useful (and enjoyable) resources”
James Newman, Former U.S. Navy cryptologist
“Professor Ming and his team’s analyses of current affairs are very far-sighted and directionally accurate. In the present media environment where it is harder to distinguish between real and fake information, SinoInsider’s professional perspectives are much needed to make sense of a perilous and unpredictable world. ”
Liu Cheng-chuan, Professor Emeritus, National Chiayi University
Previous
Next